When I was
in elementary school I felt intimidated by other students. I did not feel
smart. I would never raise my hand when questions would be asked, instead I
would avoid eye contact so the teacher would not call on me. I never wanted to
feel or look stupid in front of my peers. Unfortunately, many students feel embarrassed and
insecure about their intelligence. As a prospective educator, I often think
about what I can do to create an environment that allows students to view
intelligence as a learning process rather than a means to judge one another. I believe one of the main problems is the amount of emphasis adults place on assessments and grades. We are creating a
culture in which students feel pressured to be the “best”. They are growing up
with the mentality of “If you aren’t smart or the best at something then there
is something wrong with you.” Children should view intelligence as a learning
process and they should be taught that individuals have strengths and
weaknesses in one or several areas (pg.121).
I found the section on students with disabilities very informative; I think this topic deserves more attention, perhaps it’s own chapter. I especially liked the section on ADHD. It seems that over time more and more children have been diagnosed with this problem. As a teacher’s assistant I have witness children being diagnosed with ADHD. One particular student was placed on the drug Ritalin; I was very disturbed by the complete change of behavior this student demonstrated. The student was emotionless and since then I feel students who have ADHD should not be placed on medication. Instead students with ADHD should be offered other alternatives like counseling.
I found the section on students with disabilities very informative; I think this topic deserves more attention, perhaps it’s own chapter. I especially liked the section on ADHD. It seems that over time more and more children have been diagnosed with this problem. As a teacher’s assistant I have witness children being diagnosed with ADHD. One particular student was placed on the drug Ritalin; I was very disturbed by the complete change of behavior this student demonstrated. The student was emotionless and since then I feel students who have ADHD should not be placed on medication. Instead students with ADHD should be offered other alternatives like counseling.
As a
bilingual student I was able to reflect and relate to a lot of the material in
chapter five. It was definitely interesting to learn that older children go
through the stages of language learning faster than younger children (pg. 175).
I recall learning the complete opposite. Throughout this chapter I repeatedly
thought about the three year olds in the classroom I work in. Today a student
drew a picture for me and said, “It’s a ghost, he a bad ghost, he in big
trouble, bad ghost.” Woolfolk suggests that these mistakes show how logical and
rational children can be (pg 170.) Reading this chapter made me question why more
and more children are refusing to speak their native language. This is the case
with not only children but adults as well. I know people who are fluent in
Spanish yet refuse to speak the language in public. I don’t understand their
motive.
Culture and
diversity are words that come up very frequently in the world of education. The
goal is to create a society that values diversity. Prejudice, stereotyping, and
discrimination often go hand-in-hand, but it is also possible to have one
without the others. Woolfolk discusses how prejudice can be difficult to combat
because it can be part of our thinking process. We form schemas about people on
a daily basis to make sense of the world. (pg 221). I found it very disturbing
to learn that American classrooms are not designed for boys. Teachers have
grown accustomed to the traditional classroom model: orderly classrooms and
compliant students. This type of environment does not work for boys. Woolfolk
suggests that boys need smaller classes, and more discussions, and mentoring
programs. I believe male students need more play time or hands on learning.
Chapter 8 focused on cognitive learning. This chapter focused on how we learn
and retain information, which will prove helpful when I have to create lesson
plans. Students can only take so much information; I have to be able to separate
essential information from nonessential details. This week I felt there was a
lot of information to cover; the chapters were very long nonetheless,
informative and helpful.
You might be on to something with your theory on ADHD. They should be given counseling or some other milder alternative than placing the student on a harsh drug. We don't know what effects it will have on the student.
ReplyDeleteI was very disturbed by the complete change of behavior this student demonstrated. The student was emotionless and since then I feel students who have ADHD should not be placed on medication. Instead students with ADHD should be offered other alternatives like counseling.
Hi Diana. I also wanted to chime in on your disability and ADHD comments. I too think that this topic needs more elaboration, but I also think that some students may benefit from drug therapy (maybe in severe cases). There are ranges of severity within each disability and solutions that work for some may not work for others. This got me thinking that there is no perfect student, and maybe everyone has some sort of “handicap.” I am not trying to make light of any disabilities or handicaps, but put a different way I think that everyone has strengths and limiting weaknesses. My takeaway from the disabilities section is that teachers really do need to tailor their educational experience to each student. Each student has unique needs with or without an official disability.
ReplyDeleteHeya Diana,
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with you that children should "view intelligence as a learning process." Kids today have so much pressure to be the best and brightest, but what many of them do not realize is that instead of making it a competition, they should be seeking to be constantly learning and expanding their own personal minds. No two people are the same, and their way of learning and intelligence are part of what makes a person unique. To further comment on what Maria and David said in regards to your thoughts on ADHD, I agree that alternative methods to medication need to be sought out, especially in younger children. David's observation that "maybe everyone has some sort of "handicap"" is something I greatly concur with. As individuals we all have something that is unique just to us, even if one feels they are "just average." While talking with a friend of mine who has a brother with a learning disability, she really hit the nail on the head by saying "Eric is my brother. Sometimes people stare at him and wonder how he lives. How does he live? Positively. He makes amazing macaroni and cheese, always has a smile on his face, and always tries his best to make everyone around him happy. He has an extra chromosome, and can make a better dinner than I ever could, and is nicer that anyone I can know. We all have something "extra" that one person might see as a handicap, when really they should be looking at all the other things that make us truly special."
Good insight Diana. Good teachers are also ones who are observant to changes in student behaviors, especially as it relates to medications and other interventions. While we have no right to make our opinions known to parents and/or guardians regarding the decision to medicate a student, we can let parents know some of the changes we observe as it relates to students ability to concentrate or engage in activities. You will learn more about students with disabilities and some best practice interventions in your Intro to Students with Disabilities course. Also, thank you for sharing your experiences. Many times our experiences help shape our philosophy of education. I am sure yours includes the importance of creating a caring classroom community that supports the various needs of learning styles of the students.
ReplyDelete